Skip to content
Menu
REDD-Monitor
  • Start here
  • About REDD-Monitor
  • REDD: An introduction
  • Contact
REDD-Monitor
Pollination Group

Banking on Nature: HSBC partners with Pollination for US$6 billion “natural capital” investment

Posted on 1 September 202023 November 2020

By Chris Lang

HSBC Global Asset Management and Pollination Group have announced a series of planned billion-dollar funds targetting “natural capital”. The new venture will be called HSBC Pollination Climate Asset Management and aims to raise US$6 billion from institutional investors. But handing over conservation to bankers and neoliberal economists will be a disaster for the climate, for Indigenous Peoples and local communities, and for nature.

For more than a decade, governments, corporations, and conservation NGOs have been developing schemes to put a price on “ecosystem services”. These are supposed to be maintained as “natural capital”, under the assumption that if natural resources can be priced, they will be protected – through global policies, and by local communities.

As Bernice Maxton-Lee points out in a recent Guest Post on REDD-Monitor, the global economic system, “in which the only measure of success is increasing short term financial returns”, is the major cause of deforestation and environmental degradation.

She notes two truths underlying the global economic system:

  • everything that can be commoditised, should be;
  • the highest possible short-term financial return should determine the fate of a commodity.

Investing in “natural capital” means that questions of conservation are reduced to whether a forest is worth more money standing or clearcut.

“Nature is capital”

The HSBC Pollination webpage states that “Nature is capital” and describes the partnership as “The first large-scale investment opportunity to protect nature, and your returns.”

The webpage states that,

As the global economy shifts and the race to decarbonise assets, sectors and entire economies intensifies, there is growing demand for nature-based solutions to climate change that also diversify investment risk and offer attractive, long-term returns.

The simple truth is understood: failing to invest in the resilience of nature means failing to invest in the resilience of the economy. Nature is now the most fertile investment we have.

HSBC Pollination Climate Asset Management will offer investments in five “themes”:

  • Regenerative and sustainable agriculture
  • Sustainable forestry
  • Oceans, including sustainable fisheries, coastal restoration and blue carbon
  • Biodiversity and wildlife protection and restoration
  • Nature based projects that generate returns from reducing greenhouse emissions.

HSBC Global Asset Management and Pollination aim to “create the world’s largest dedicated natural capital asset management company”. They plan to launch a first fund in 2021, aiming to raise US$1 billion, followed by a US$2 billion carbon credit fund.

A bunch of bankers

The Pollination Group was founded last year by Martijn Wilder and Tony O’Sullivan. Wilder was head of Baker & McKenzie’s global climate law and sustainable-finance practice for 20 years. He’s also President of WWF Australia. O’Sullivan was head of investment banking at Lazard.

The team at Pollination Group includes: John Morton, who was a senior director for energy and climate under President Obama; Patrick Suckling, who was Australia’s environment ambassador; Rob Jesudason, former chief financial officer at the Commonwealth Bank; Sam Mostyn, chair of Citi Australia; Markus Wandt, former Investment Director Private Equity at Mayfair Vermögensverwaltung SE; Kate Rayson who led Qantas Future Planet, the world’s largest airline offset programme; James Cameroon, co-founder of Climate Change Capital, “the world’s first green investment bank”; and Christof Kutscher, former Global Chairman of AXA Investment Managers.

John Morton told CNBC that,

“We are helping kind of pioneer this asset class or at least take an asset class which is quite small, to scale at a moment when it’s really needed by the institutional investor community, certainly needed by the planet, and we feel we can generate strong returns at the same time.”

HSBC Pollination Climate Asset Management may well make money for a small number of already very rich people. But a US$2 billion carbon credit fund will guarantee that millions of tons of greenhouse gas emissions will enter the atmosphere. At this stage of the climate crisis we urgently need to cut emissions to zero. And not to “net zero”, Pollination Group’s target, which allows corporations to continue polluting while relying on others to reduce emissions for them.

Obviously, this new venture fundamentally fails to address the link between the climate crisis and capitalism. On the contrary, it strengthens the link – thus helping exacerbate the climate crisis.

 

  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Reddit
  • email
  • Facebook

3 thoughts on “Banking on Nature: HSBC partners with Pollination for US$6 billion “natural capital” investment”

  1. Carlo Castellani says:
    2 September 2020 at 9:37 am

    That “the global economic system, “in which the only measure of success is increasing short term financial returns”, is the major cause of deforestation and environmental degradation.” is a nice theory; probably an important component od environmental degradation. If correct we should obseve a relation between its severity and economic and political systems around the world in space and time. I don’t see any correlation; while I see a clear correlation of government incentives and law enforcement with environmental degradation. Any evidence that Cuba or North Corea protect their environment better than the average? Wherever I travel I see forest regrowth in countries where Communism is replaced by market. On the other extreme it’s for me difficult to select countries where free market (= no incentives) and rule of law are sufficiently applied. My conclusion is that while free market is certainly an environmental threat if let completely free (but no economics theory states that it must ever be let unregulated by a political authority!), the main cause of degradation is governmental policy.

  2. Julian says:
    21 November 2020 at 9:33 pm

    Hi there,
    @Chris Lang I wanted to ask if you were able to gather in which projects HSBC & pollination have already “invested”. Do you know? Will be extremely important to monitor to dismantle their narrative…

  3. Chris Lang says:
    23 November 2020 at 1:06 pm

    @Julian – As far as I’m aware, HSBC and Pollination haven’t announced which projects they are going to invest in. The press release, dated 26 August 2020, states:

    HSBC Global Asset Management Limited and Pollination Group Holdings Limited, the specialist climate change advisory and investment firm, today announced that they have entered into a joint venture agreement to establish HSBC Pollination Climate Asset Management – subject to regulatory approval. The partnership will aim to create the world’s largest natural capital manager and is the first large-scale venture to mainstream natural capital as an asset class.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

SUBSCRIBE!

Enter your email address to receive notification of new posts.

Recent themes
Natural Climate Solutions
WWF's conservation scandals
Aviation and offsetting
Conservation Watch

Recent Comments

  • Fábio Alkmin on “REDD does nothing to address the crisis of endless economic growth.” Interview with Chris Lang, REDD-Monitor, by Fábio Alkmin, PhD student at the University of São Paulo, Brazil
  • Kathleen McCroskey on Papua New Guinea Environmental Alliance demands proper REDD safeguards and implementation of moratorium on voluntary carbon market REDD projects
  • Kathleen McCroskey on “REDD does nothing to address the crisis of endless economic growth.” Interview with Chris Lang, REDD-Monitor, by Fábio Alkmin, PhD student at the University of São Paulo, Brazil
  • shahid a on “REDD does nothing to address the crisis of endless economic growth.” Interview with Chris Lang, REDD-Monitor, by Fábio Alkmin, PhD student at the University of São Paulo, Brazil
  • shahid on James Moore sentenced to more than 11 years in prison for his role in the Bar Works scam

Recent Posts

  • Stop the Racist Conservation Model!
  • Business as usual at WWF Germany: Conflict of interest allegations; Executive Director resigns; Whistleblower threatened with dismissal; WWF Germany covers up
  • Papua New Guinea Environmental Alliance demands proper REDD safeguards and implementation of moratorium on voluntary carbon market REDD projects
  • “REDD does nothing to address the crisis of endless economic growth.” Interview with Chris Lang, REDD-Monitor, by Fábio Alkmin, PhD student at the University of São Paulo, Brazil
  • Offsetting is not an option if we are serious about addressing the climate crisis. My response to Hartmut Graßl

Recent Comments

  • Fábio Alkmin on “REDD does nothing to address the crisis of endless economic growth.” Interview with Chris Lang, REDD-Monitor, by Fábio Alkmin, PhD student at the University of São Paulo, Brazil
  • Kathleen McCroskey on Papua New Guinea Environmental Alliance demands proper REDD safeguards and implementation of moratorium on voluntary carbon market REDD projects
  • Kathleen McCroskey on “REDD does nothing to address the crisis of endless economic growth.” Interview with Chris Lang, REDD-Monitor, by Fábio Alkmin, PhD student at the University of São Paulo, Brazil
  • shahid a on “REDD does nothing to address the crisis of endless economic growth.” Interview with Chris Lang, REDD-Monitor, by Fábio Alkmin, PhD student at the University of São Paulo, Brazil
  • shahid on James Moore sentenced to more than 11 years in prison for his role in the Bar Works scam

Issues and Organisations

30x30 AB 32 Andes Amazon Boiler rooms California Can REDD save ... ? Carbon accounting Carbon Credits Carbon Offsets CDM Conservation-Watch Conservation International COP21 Paris Deforestation FCPF FERN Financing REDD Forest definition Fossil fuels FPP Friends of the Earth FSC Green Climate Fund Greenpeace Guest post ICAO Illegal logging Indigenous Peoples Natural Climate Solutions NGO statements Plantations Poznan R-M interview REDD and rights REDD in the news Risk RSPO-Watch Safeguards Sengwer The Nature Conservancy UN-REDD UNFCCC World Bank WRM WWF

Countries

Australia Bolivia Brazil Cambodia Cameroon Canada China Colombia Congo Basin region Costa Rica DR Congo Ecuador El Salvador European Union France Germany Guatemala Guyana Honduras India Indonesia Kenya Laos Madagascar Malaysia Mexico Nicaragua Norway Panama Papua New Guinea Paraguay Peru Philippines Republic of Congo Sierra Leone Sweden Tanzania Thailand Uganda UK Uncategorized United Arab Emirates USA Vietnam West Papua
©2022 REDD-Monitor | Powered by WordPress and Superb Themes!